Metcalfa Honeydew Honey
The Story
In eastern North America, where it is native, the citrus flatid planthopper (Metcalfa) is scarce: one or two twigs on a whole tree usually carry it and there is no known production of Metcalfa honeydew honey. First found in Europe near Treviso, Italy, in 1979, it spread across the lowland plains and became a major pest of orchards and vineyards, and a honey: beekeepers carried their hives down from the mountains to collect its honeydew. In 1987 Italian entomologists brought over the wasp that preys on it at home, to control it.
The planthopper is a sap-feeding insect under a centimetre long, dusted with a bluish-white wax; pruinosa is Latin for frosted. Its young and its adults feed on the sap of trees and shrubs and pass the surplus sugar as sticky drops on the leaves. Honey bees collect the drops, and the honey they make from them is a honeydew honey.
Characteristics
Liquid, the honey runs from dark amber to almost black, about 100 mm on the Pfund scale, the darkest mean colour of the honey types in the European descriptive sheets (Persano Oddo and Piro 2004). It turns brown when it sets, and it sets slowly, staying thick and stringy for a long time.
It smells warm and fruity, of cooked fruit, fig jam and malt over a vegetal note of tomato paste, and it tastes slightly to moderately sweet, often a little salty and faintly astringent (Italy’s national sheet).
Analysts measure its acidity high, at times above the 50 milliequivalents of acid per kilogram the European honey directive allows, while tasting panels rate the sourness from weak (the European sheet) to distinct (Italy’s national sheet).
Click to Display — The Details: honeydew source, sensory profile, pairings, health and what gives it its character
Honeydew Sources:
- Primary: Citrus flatid planthopper (Metcalfa pruinosa). Host: Field maple (Acer campestre), ash (Fraxinus spp.), black locust (Robinia pseudoacacia), bramble (Rubus spp.), plane (Platanus spp.) and other broadleaved trees and shrubs of lowland hedgerows, ditch banks and woodland edges
Nectar Contributors:
- Background: Late-summer flowers of the surrounding fields and hedgerows, varying by site (Multiple species, undocumented)
Bee Species:
The western honey bee, Apis mellifera. On the Friuli plain the bees work the honeydew in the morning and again late in the afternoon (Barbattini 2001). A Greek beekeeping review of 2016 adds that they take the fresh drops, since older ones skin over or grow mould, and cap the cells quickly, because the honeydew they bring in is already dense.
Color:
Dark amber to almost black when liquid, brown once crystallised
Flavor Profile:
Malty and caramelised, with cooked fruit and a savoury, vegetal edge; low to medium in sweetness, often slightly salty
Tasting Notes:
Very thick and stringy on the spoon, with a fairly persistent finish that can turn slightly astringent, as Italy’s national descriptive sheet records it.
The odour shifts with where the honeydew was gathered. In Piana’s 2020 descriptive sheets for Italian honeys, the honeys of central Italy lean to cooked grape must, long-cooked jam, balsamic vinegar, maple syrup and malt, and those of the Po plain to cooked vegetables, boiled chard, pumpkin, brewer’s yeast and bread crust, together recalling sun-dried tomato or tomato paste.
Aroma:
Warm and caramelised: fig jam, cooked fruit and malt over a savoury note of tomato paste and cooked greens
Defining Compounds:
Minerals, read as electrical conductivity, and the enzyme diastase: both have the highest means of the honey types in the European descriptive sheets (Persano Oddo and Piro 2004). Those sheets rest almost entirely on Italian samples; a Greek beekeeping review reported that honey from Evros analysed at the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki measured lower in both.
Sugars: little fructose and glucose and a high share of longer sugars, with maltotriose always present and melezitose only in traces. In Italy’s national sheet that pair, with the higher acidity, separates it from silver fir honeydew honey. The maltotriose is thought to be made by the insect’s own enzymes (Barbattini 2001), and the honey carries dextrins of its own.
No laboratory method recognised internationally separates it from oak honeydew honey or other broadleaf honeydews (International Honey Commission, 2008); in Italy it is identified by tasting panel, by microscope and by where it was made (Piana 2020).
Forage Origin:
Metcalfa pruinosa is a planthopper of the family Flatidae, described in 1830. Its English name is citrus flatid planthopper; it is found on citrus, but it feeds on a wide range of woody plants. It is native to eastern and central North America, from southern Canada to Texas and Florida, and to Bermuda, where its numbers stay low: in July 2000 Wilson and Lucchi counted 72 on four 50-metre forest transects in Missouri and 11,571 on four in Tuscany.
It has one generation a year. Eggs laid in bark crevices in September overwinter; hatching begins in mid-May and goes on in stages for about two months, and the young, called nymphs, wrapped in white waxy threads, grow through five stages (Regione Veneto; EPPO). The adults, seven to nine millimetres long and brown to grey under a bluish-white wax, appear in early July and mate at night in September and October. Nymphs and adults both feed on sap and excrete honeydew.
It feeds on more than 300 kinds of plant, conifers excepted (Piana 2020). The bees take its honeydew from the broadleaved trees, shrubs and brambles of the lowlands and low hills, up to about 400 metres: field maple, ash, black locust, bramble and plane along ditch banks, woodland edges and the hedges between fields. The make-up of the honeydew is thought to follow the plant the insects mostly fed on (Barbattini 2001).
The flow is irregular. It rises in the days after ordinary rain, which washes off the old drops, and the bees work it hardest then. Heat, dry air and wind dry the drops at once, beating rain washes the insects off the plants, and a run of dry years cuts the crop (Barbattini 2001; Italy’s national beekeepers’ union, Unaapi). The same drops feed sooty mould, which blackens the leaves.
The bees also bring in nectar: pollen in Piedmont samples comes from late-flowering plants of the surrounding fields, daisies, knapweeds and plants of the carrot family among them, beside sunflower and maize (L’Apis 2007).
Pairings:
One Italian producer pairs it with mascarpone and a quadrupel-style Trappist beer. Aspromiele, a Piedmont beekeepers’ association, suggests medium, dry cheeses that are not too fatty, Piedmont toma cheeses among them, and stirring the honey into warm milk, which suits its malty side. As an ingredient, Unaapi suggests it in dressings and seasonings, where its salty, acid and vegetal note works, and the same producer uses it where a malt-like sweetness is wanted.
Origin Story
On the Friuli plain in north-eastern Italy, beekeepers took large summer crops of the insect’s honeydew from 1987 (Barbattini 2001). Italian buyers took little dark honey, so most of it went abroad: in 1994 the beekeepers surveyed in Udine province produced 383 tonnes of honey, 46 percent of it honeydew, and exported more than 60 percent of their Metcalfa honey, mainly to Germany, against 6 percent of their other honeys.
In the early 1990s German importers challenged it, because it tested positive for dextrins. Laboratories at Hohenheim and Udine analysed honeydew collected from the insect on plane trees near Udine in August 1995 and found that the dextrins come from the honeydew itself (Held, Zoratti and Vorwohl 1997). By 2000 the honey had its own Italian national descriptive sheet, and today the Osservatorio Nazionale Miele (National Honey Observatory) describes it, in one of the sixteen Italian honey sheets it presents, as melata di bosco (summer forest honeydew).
The insect was recorded in France in the mid-1980s, in Croatia by the mid-1990s and in Greece in the early 2000s (INRAE; Strauss 2010), and the honey followed. In France it was new in 2002, when Henri Clément’s honey guide reported that miel de metcalfa (Metcalfa honey), “inconnu il y a seulement dix ans” (unknown only ten years ago), was appearing on the market, and called it the youngest of French honeys and the only one named for an insect. In Corsica, where the insect arrived in the 1990s, beekeepers had to find new sites and routes and explain a new honey to their customers; Antonin Adam’s 2019 thesis calls it “une aubaine pour les apiculteurs” (a windfall for beekeepers), made almost every year.
Croatia’s Ministry of Agriculture wrote it into the national quality scheme: its 2023 Dokazana kvaliteta (Proven Quality) honey specification lists medun od medećeg cvrčka (Metcalfa honeydew honey) among the honeys of the lowland area. In Greece it was first found at beekeeping scale at Soufli, in Evros, in 2015, according to Andreas Thrasyvoulou of the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki.
Italian packers usually leave the insect off the label, and the jar reads melata (honeydew), as Italy’s national sheet notes, or miele di bosco (forest honey), a name a 2007 ministry circular allows (Piana 2020). In France and Croatia it can be sold as miel de forêt (forest honey) or medljikovac (honeydew honey), with the insect named in the beekeeper’s listing or, in Croatia, the national specification. In Greece it is sold under the insect’s name, as Metcalfa honey (Μέλι Μετκάλφα, meli metkalfa).
After the first large crops the harvest grew less dependable. A parasitic wasp, Neodryinus typhlocybae, released in Italy from 1987 and in France from 1996, reduced the insect’s numbers (Vétek et al. 2019; Strauss 2010). Unaapi, the national union of Italian beekeepers' associations, points chiefly to a run of dry years; two entomologists at the University of Milan credit the wasp (Lupi and Colombo, 2021). In its report on the 2024 season, the Osservatorio Nazionale Miele found Metcalfa honeydew down sharply, gone entirely from many areas.
Harvest & Forage
The flow runs from July into early September, and the honey comes off the hives from August. In Italy it lasts from late July to the first days of September (Unaapi); Croatia’s specification has the honeydew appearing in July and the honey extracted in August; Greek bees collect it in July and August (Thrasyvoulou, 2015); and Clément’s French guide of 2002 gives July and August.
The nymphs start hatching in mid-May (Regione Veneto), but the bees leave their honeydew alone while lucerne and the hay meadows are in flower. On the Friuli plain they turn to it in the second week of July, as the lucerne finishes and the meadows are mown; they take most while nymphs and adults are on the plants together, and less as the adults take over (Barbattini 2001).
The honeydew is a lowland crop, so beekeepers bring hives down to it. Friulian beekeepers moved hives from the mountains to the infested plain, a practice they called nomadismo inverso (reverse migration), while a few who sold at the door moved theirs away from it, because their Italian customers wanted light honey (Barbattini 2001). In Corsica in 2014 one beekeeper took every hive down to the honeydew, explaining that in August the bees have nothing else to eat, and could fill two supers (Adam 2019). In 2017 a beekeeper from the Peloponnese trucked hives to Soufli, in Evros, for “a new honey, metcalfa” (Efimerida ton Syntakton, 2017).
The honey is slow to extract and hard to spin once the weather cools. In a Friuli survey more than a quarter of beekeepers bought bigger extractors, and 40 percent of those with more than 70 hives warmed the honey gently (Barbattini 2001). In good years the bees bring the long flow into the summer honeys, mixing its aroma, colour and body into lucerne, sunflower and clover honey (Unaapi), which complicates monofloral harvests.
Crops vary from year to year and have fallen over time. On the Friuli plain they ran above 40 kg a hive, gathered in under two months, from 1987 to the mid-1990s, and fell to a mean of 22 kg by about 2001 (Barbattini 2001); in the regional atlas of Italian honeys, reprinted in 2013, the honeydew there had become mostly a component of summer multifloral honeys (Persano Oddo, Piana and Ricciardelli D’Albore). In Corsica the Institut de l’abeille (ITSAP, the French bee institute) found in 2019 that the maquis honeydews, mostly Metcalfa, had grown less reliable over five years.
Beekeeping Context
Beekeepers and farmers see the insect from opposite sides. To fruit and vine growers it is a pest that coats the leaves in sticky honeydew and mould; to beekeepers on the plains it became a summer crop, and Clément wrote in 2002 that farmers would try to eradicate it, “au grand dam des apiculteurs” (to the beekeepers’ dismay). Bees working honeydew on infested plants may also be exposed when those plants are sprayed (Vétek et al. 2019).
In Friuli the honeydew also served as the bees’ winter food. Colonies wintered on it very rarely suffered dysentery or Nosema, and some mountain beekeepers moved hives to the infested plain only to fill the brood combs, where the colony raises its young, with winter stores. Because the flow ran into September, treatments against varroa came later, and more than 45 percent of Friuli beekeepers changed how often they visited their hives (Barbattini 2001).
Source Regions
- Italy, Po plain to Molise and Campania – Metcalfa pruinosa: Metcalfa honeydew honey (Miele di melata di metcalfa), a summer lowland harvest.
- France, lower Rhône valley and Corsica – Metcalfa pruinosa: Metcalfa honeydew honey (Miellat de Metcalfa), sold in Corsica among the maquis honeydews.
- Greece, Evros and the Nestos valley – Metcalfa pruinosa: Metcalfa honeydew honey (Μέλι Μετκάλφα, meli metkalfa), sold under the insect’s name.
- Croatia, the lowlands – Metcalfa pruinosa: Metcalfa honeydew honey (Medun od medećeg cvrčka), a lowland type in the national quality specification, extracted in August.
Translations
- Miele di melata di metcalfa – Italian
- Miellat de Metcalfa – French
- Μέλι Μετκάλφα (meli metkalfa) – Greek
- Medun od medećeg cvrčka – Croatian
- Metcalfahonig – German
- Metcalfahoning – Dutch
- Škržatov med – Slovene
Certifications
Qualità Controllata (QC), Emilia-Romagna – The region’s quality mark for farms that follow its integrated-production rules. The honey rules list Metcalfa honeydew among the single-source honeys the mark covers, each held to the Italian national descriptive sheet. (Italian translated to English )
Dokazana kvaliteta (Proven Quality), honey – Croatia’s national quality label, granted for honey by the Ministry of Agriculture on 6 October 2023 at the request of the Hrvatski pčelarski savez (Croatian Beekeepers’ Association). Its specification lists medun od medećeg cvrčka, Metcalfa honeydew, among the honeys of the lowland area. (Croatian translated to English
)